Gallaghers Steakhouse
Company Details
Tuesday: 11:45AM-11:30PM
Wednesday: 11:45AM-11:30PM
Thursday: 11:45AM-11:30PM
Friday: 11:45AM-11:30PM
Saturday: 11:45AM-11:30PM
Sunday: 11:45AM-10:30PM
Contact Information
New York, New York, 10019
United States
Gallaghers Steakhouse Reviews
Submitted by Michael Wertz on 09/05/2022
Michael Wertz 5 stars rating.
It's some of the best steak in the world.
There is a reason this is a world famous Steakhouse, because they deliver on the hype. It was easily one of the best steaks I have ever had.
As you enter you walk by the dry aging room, where you can see all of the steaks waiting to age. That alone is an impressive sight.
And while it's not exactly cheap (menu pictures are from 2019), the prices are very reasonable for a steakhouse of this quality anywhere, let alone in the heart of Manhattan.
If you get a chance, go.
Submitted by James on 08/23/2022
James 4 stars rating.
4.5/5. Very good steakhouse! The service was great and the food was very good. The Porterhouse is at par with all the other top steakhouses in NY, like Peter Luger etc. You can see the steaks being cooked from some seats. The fried calamari, creamed spinach, porterhouse, and dim sum are good. The fries and macaroni are decent, nothing special. The cheese cake and key lime pie were also pretty good but for $12 a slice not that good. The waiters were fast and very friendly. The only cons were it gets pretty loud and rowdy and many of the tables and seats are packed tightly together.
Submitted by Rebecca S on 08/23/2022
Rebecca S 5 stars rating.
We received absolutely wonderful service and enjoyed spectacular food. Our server was very kind and checked in on us on a frequent enough basis. The food tasted wonderful. We ordered a steak for two medium and one medium well, both cooked to perfection. The Mac and cheese tasted wonderful, the calamari crunchy and tasted fresh, the cream spinach more on the spinach side, and the deserts were absolutely divine. After a day at work, getting to enjoy such spectacular food was an absolute treat.
Submitted by Faisal Tahir on 07/30/2022
Faisal Tahir 5 stars rating.
Rated as one of the best steakhouse of NYC and after being there can say that. Food, the ambiance and the service is really superb. The meat is juicy, people are friendly and portion size are big. Chocolate cake is average. The place is buzzing with people so do book and highly recommend for steak house
Submitted by Jessica Mark on 06/02/2022
Jessica Mark 5 stars rating.
If you’re in search a classic American steakhouse, Gallagher’s is a solid pick. First time coming here on a Sunday night for a celebratory birthday dinner and was greeted by a pleasant and welcoming host. We were brought to the dining room that was bustling with diners indulging in food and conversation. The restaurant has a very old-school New York feel; with dim lights, walls adorned with framed photos of iconic celebs, and red leather bounded booths and chairs.
My family and I were seated in a booth that was spacious and comfortable, with plenty of room to spread our elbows. The menu has a lot to offer but we ordered a good variety for a “complete” meal. Our picks included the French onion soup, baked clams casino, the wedge salad, the porterhouse, a side of mashed potatoes, creamed spinach, and sautéed mushrooms. Everything was cooked to perfection but my favorites had to be the French onion soup, baked clams (*chef’s kiss), and surprisingly, the mashed potatoes. The mashed potatoes did not include gravy if you’re wondering, but it really didn’t need anything additional. With all that food, we had a bit of room for dessert. How could one pass up creme brûlée? I’m so glad I never say no to dessert because it was heavenly.
Sometimes it’s the food that makes the dining experience, but the service here was amazing as well. Our waiter went above and beyond to make our dining experience a memorable one, and checked in often to see if everything was to our liking.
It was my first time dining at Gallagher’s, but it most certainly won’t be the last.
*Be sure to make reservations.
Submitted by Deborah East on 04/11/2022
Deborah East 5 stars rating.
We made reservations for Monday night before a show. It was very busy so we were glad to have a reservation. We were met at the door with friendly faces and an enormous meet locker. What a nice start to a wonderful meal. Even though the staff was very busy and moving very quickly, they still managed to be very attentive, efficient and make us feel like family. It definitely has an old school steakhouse feeling with old school service. We arrived early and sat at the bar for some drinks before our reservation. The cocktails were unique and very tasty. We were taken to our table right on time and sat near the kitchen. Usually I would not want to be near the kitchen but in this case it was entertaining to see the magic in making our steaks. We went all out during our meal and had two appetizers, two side dishes, shared a porterhouse and a bottle of wine. This meal was about $500. The food was really good but not the best ever; however, combined with great service and the cool old school feeling, I’m giving it the five star rating. I will say, the wine selection was varied and unique and had a variety of price points. I’m glad we chose this place and would return.
Submitted by Benjamin Skyler Blate on 03/27/2022
Benjamin Skyler Blate 5 stars rating.
I was in New York City today and was told Gallagher Steakhouses had the best steak in Manhattan so I decided to give it a try and that might have been the best decision I ever made. When you first walk in it has a vintage but classy comfortable vibe to it, the bartender who was amazing Erin was a big help in what I ended getting. The lintel soup was great not to filling but very flavorful exactly what you would want. The filet was absolutely divine, melted right in my mouth and cut like butter, the aroma was excellent with each bite it was an explosion of unique flavor. That might have been the best steak I ever consumed. The cheesecake was delicious it was a great treat to end my lunch, it was fluffy yet somehow filling, couldn’t have enjoyed my stay more!!
Submitted by Yan Ong on 01/15/2022
Yan Ong 4 stars rating.
We'd been to Keens a couple of nights before and it was so good we wanted to have another steak experience to treat ourselves for our last night in New York. The service is outstanding at Gallagher's - the best in the city.
We ordered the Rib Eye, Mac & Cheese, Fries and Sauteed Mushrooms. Pecan pie for dessert. To be honest the food overall is not as tasty as Keens but it's still an overall enjoyable dining experience.
Submitted by Madina Turan on 01/13/2022
Madina Turan 5 stars rating.
Absolutely delicious food and atmosphere at this old school style steakhouse. It’s so warm and inviting. The bar area is beautiful, would love to sit here next time. My husband and I were seated in a cozy table in the main dining room- loved it! The service was great. Cocktails excellent. For food, we ordered the porterhouse for two, creamed spinach, and Mac and cheese. Everything was absolutely delicious!! We got a chocolate layer cake to go. Gallagher’s may be my favorite steakhouse in NYC- loved it.
Submitted by Histio Mom on 11/20/2021
Histio Mom 5 stars rating.
Absolutely wonderful! Service was impeccable. Our server was Patrick. He was incredibly attentive without being obtrusive. Managers checked on us multiple times as well to ensure all was well. There was a fair amount of ambient noise as to be expected but not such that we couldn’t easily communicate with each other. The food was beyond incredible. Loved everything we had. Will gladly visit again
