Carmines Italian Restaurant - Times Square
Company Details
Tuesday: 11:30AM-10:30PM
Wednesday: 11:30AM-10:30PM
Thursday: 11:30AM-10:30PM
Friday: 11:30AM-10:30PM
Saturday: 11:30AM-10:30PM
Sunday: 11:30AM-10:30PM
Contact Information
New York, New York, 10036
United States
Carmines Italian Restaurant - Times Square Reviews
Submitted by MD Steele on 07/23/2022
MD Steele 3 stars rating.
Ordered the eggplant parmigiana and it was pretty good. It tasted like it was previously frozen. The tiramisu was what I was really looking forward to and was thoroughly disappointed. For the first ever this dessert came with chocolate chips in the top…what a terrible choice. This definitely diminishes the integrity of the dish. Not the Carmine’s I have come to know and love. Hopefully it was just a bad night.
Submitted by DMarx on 07/22/2022
DMarx 5 stars rating.
My time night in New York. The sights the smells and the culture. I was hyper stimulated by Times Square, the abundance of people, and the sightseeing and grew famished as the day dragged on. Our first night destination for dinner was Carmines. I had been pointed in the right direction by some friends who had visited before. They said the portions were served family style and never disappointed. I can say they were correct. We ordered calamari salad and a few other plates and ended up with too much food to even consider leftovers. These family style meals could feed multiple families with ease. I felt like a made guy sitting and eating in this great atmosphere. Very Tony Soprano. Our servers were delightful and the food came out promptly. The drinks were fantastic. I consider this a must try for anyone visiting the Empire State.
Submitted by Eduardo Rodrigues on 07/20/2022
Eduardo Rodrigues 5 stars rating.
Great place!
Delicious New York's Style Italian Food. The crew is very polite and friendly. The drinks are great.
You can wait for your table at the bar, or even have dinner there, while watch sports on the TVs.
The portions are huge, for like 4 or 5 adults each.
Submitted by Joaquin Diaz on 07/15/2022
Joaquin Diaz 5 stars rating.
A fun place to visit and eat. The portions are way too big for one person so either come extremely hungry or with people ready to eat. The food is delicious and the noisy environment makes the place a fun time. The service was second to none, in fact kudos to Miguel for a tremendous job. He is attentive, professional, and willing to help.
Submitted by Selena Pagan on 07/09/2022
Selena Pagan 5 stars rating.
The food here was amazing. We stopped in after seeing Phantom on Broadway and it was such a delight. The food, drinks and service were amazing. It is family style dining and our waitress helped up pick just the right amount of food for all of us. If you are thinking about it, you won't be disappointed!
Submitted by Giannina Vargas on 07/03/2022
Giannina Vargas 5 stars rating.
A bit overcrowded and waiting time was long, although we had a reservation. Food taste was great and portions are huge (each dish.serves at least 4 very generous portions. We had two different pasta dishes and both were delicious. They keep the Italian homemade characteristic flavors despite.of the amounts of food they cook. I would definitely come back and recommend as a "must visit" when in NYC
Submitted by Sarah Slattery on 06/28/2022
Sarah Slattery 5 stars rating.
The waitstaff was incredible! The gentleman who took care of us made sure we made appropriate selections of our food. He saved us so much money by being honest!! The cocktails were yummy and we ordered pasta with vodka sauce, which was delicious. There was parmesan cheese in a container on the table. The bread was phenomenal and I ate so much of it I actually felt so full I could hardly move. We were tucked away in a great location by a window. Would absolutely go again when we travel back to NYC!!
Submitted by Jason Whittle on 11/26/2021
Jason Whittle 5 stars rating.
Legendary Italian restaurant just off Times Square. Sit back and watch the hustle and bustle. Killer portions at very reasonable prices. Frequented by tourists and locals alike, which is a good sign.
Submitted by Ryan Miller on 10/31/2021
Ryan Miller 5 stars rating.
We have not been back here for 20 yrs . Let us just say it was freaking awesome! We had the rigatoni bolenese ....and garlic and pesto spagethii. The garlic bread was made to perfection....hard on the outside soft on the inside. The chopped Salad was amazing also. The service was good and not a bad price for all of the food we got. We got in right at our reservation time so that was a plus also. Check it out you won't be disappointed.
Submitted by Ines Rios on 10/05/2021
Ines Rios 5 stars rating.
Incredible experience! The servers were amazing recommending and guiding our journey, we had the best steak and shared a huge pasta, wine paring was great and the dessert topped everything making it a day to remember, we were celebrating a bday and the staff sang with us, we walked around the place remembering every movie we have seen it in and I definitely think this is one of those places you need to visit at least once in New York! Great food, great people, unforgettable experience.
