BLT Prime
Company Details
Tuesday: 5-10PM
Wednesday: 5-10PM
Thursday: 5-10PM
Friday: 5-10PM
Saturday: 5-10PM
Sunday: 5-10PM
Contact Information
New York, New York, 10021
United States
BLT Prime Reviews
Submitted by Howard T on 09/04/2022
Howard T 3 stars rating.
The steak was quality. Medium rare temperature came out probably slightly on the medium side but still good. While the service was good, food took a long long time to come out, almost unbearably long (over an hour from ordering to entree being served). I would rather go back to BLT Steak in the future, as it has essentially parity in menu.
Submitted by Larry Raab on 07/15/2022
Larry Raab 5 stars rating.
I forgot to take any pictures because the food looked to amazing to wait. The staff was awesome and the food was divine. I highly suggest going here if you ever want a great steak meal. The tuna tartare app was a delight.
Submitted by Lee Orloff on 07/02/2022
Lee Orloff 3 stars rating.
I live nearby and made a reservation for 2, since that was required. When I called to reschedule, I spoke to Sergio and revealed that I would come alone. He is perhaps Italian (I don’t know) and said it was fine for me to come as a single. About an hour later, I saw that the reservation had been cancelled by the restaurant. I have never received such a show of BLATANT DISCRIMINATION!! And for what? I’m from France and this would Never happen: Never
After the restaurant read what I wrote, Sergio called me to talk and , I learned that this was a big misunderstanding. I learned that in order to modify a reservation, the restaurant must first cancel it.Sergio could not have been more kind and accommodating. I will go there with or without a companion. Can’t rate the food since I didn’t eat.
Submitted by Joanne Hobbs on 06/13/2022
Joanne Hobbs 5 stars rating.
This was our first time at this wonderful restaurant. Quite an impromptu decision. It was 5:15pm, no reservations and they gave us a booth for two. Nice touch. We ordered two margaritas. Delish. Perfectly done without fuss. Then the bread crips with pate.
A Wow!! I was now full but I wanted to keep eating. We had the calamari and the artichoke hearts. Another absolutely delish moment. The sauces that came with them were a wonderful addition. The puffed cheese bread was the best I’ve had. Then the steak, a filet, perfectly prepared and seasoned although the large salt container on the table was a nice addition. I didn’t need salt but I loved the salt shaker. The corn side was also amazing, spicy and more like a pudding. Here’s the most surprising part of the dinner. We ordered a piece of the chocolate cake to go. A many layered scrumptious looking piece of cake. I will be honest, I don’t like desserts. I rarely eat them and if I do, it’s a mouthful. I especially never eat chocolate cake, I’m more a vanilla person. Well, when I tasted that piece of chocolate cake at home I could not believe how good it was. I mean, I ate half and now the second night (and just as good) I’m unable to contain myself. I am so glad we decided to stop and have dinner here. I will certainly be back.
Submitted by G C on 06/02/2022
G C 5 stars rating.
Amazing steaks & desserts. Order the filet mignon, New York strip, Kansas City steak, Sole fish, tuna tartare, and salads. The chef threw in cheese cake, chocolate cake and popovers. Everything is perfectly prepared and taste great (even if we ordered as pick up and brought the food home.)
Will def purchase steaks from BLT prime again in the future. Recommended!
Submitted by Dan Dempsey on 05/27/2022
Dan Dempsey 5 stars rating.
Wow and wow!
It was our first dinner out since having our baby and our first time going to BLT on the UES. Our meal was great, but our waiter Michael really made our first night dinner out in months awesome.
Because of Michael’s great service we will definitely be back sooner than later.
Submitted by Raffy Tapia on 04/10/2022
Raffy Tapia 5 stars rating.
very comfortable atmosphere, service all the details present, I shared salmon and steak both excellent ,the perfect wine list
Submitted by Anthony Jaswinski on 12/04/2021
Anthony Jaswinski 5 stars rating.
We had the untraditional Thanksgiving with BLT Steak UES and it was wonderful. The popovers are great as always and the steak perfectly done at medium rare with a wonderful crust. Go for the potato skins because they are 4 star potato skins! The service and staff were excellent, friendly and attentive but never intrusive. It was truly just a good vibe w guests and staff. We used to come here when it was Payard (Frankie, you are missed). Then the Arlington/Lexington Club. I'm glad that BLT has the beautiful space now because it has a very special and warm soul.
Submitted by Kyle Cooks on 08/17/2021
Kyle Cooks 5 stars rating.
This steakhouse was amazing. The staff was super friendly and my waiter was awesome (shout out to Wilson). He was friendly and explained the menu very well. The food was amazing as well. I will definitely be coming back here.
Submitted by Shai Shani on 03/24/2021
shai shani 5 stars rating.
BLT Prime - an old school steakhouse.
No doubt one of the best steak in Manhattan.
The complementry bread as a wellcome, was surprisingly amaizing, and the steaks were perfect done.
When such a meal accompanied with a good wine and a professional service the enjoyment is perfect.
