Stelton Pizza
Company Details
Tuesday: 12-8PM
Wednesday: 12-8PM
Thursday: 12-8PM
Friday: 12-8PM
Saturday: 12-8PM
Sunday: 12-8PM
Contact Information
Piscataway, New Jersey, 08854
United States
Stelton Pizza Reviews
Submitted by Ms Foodie “Foodie Chick” on 07/09/2022
Ms Foodie “Foodie Chick” 1 stars rating.
Order through the slice app. Never again!!! They did not have what I ordered. No substitute and to make matters worse. We ordered Alfredo with chicken and did not get the chicken. When we call slice to report the problem, they stated they had to investigate and would call back within 24 hours. We are still waiting for an update.
Submitted by Eric Hansen on 06/22/2022
Eric Hansen 5 stars rating.
Great food, staff super friendly. I normally don't recommend but Stelton Pizza is one of those outstanding places
Submitted by Darkened King on 06/19/2022
darkened king 1 stars rating.
i ordered garlic knots and this is what i received. Absolutely disappointed.
Submitted by Isidria [Sid] on 06/10/2022
isidria [Sid] 4 stars rating.
Got 3 of the meat ball appetizer and garlic knots. Both were good, needed salt IMO but that might just be me. Staff was friendly, prices very reasonable.
Submitted by Andrea Retan on 05/17/2022
Andrea Retan 5 stars rating.
Stelton Pizza is one of the few delicious ???? pizza shops near me. The chef and staff are all very friendly, too! Buffalo chicken is where it's at!
Submitted by Alyssa Cardella on 02/14/2022
alyssa cardella 4 stars rating.
Pizza was really good although the lady called my date when we were five minutes away and spoiled my Valentine's surprise. She asked if we wanted the heart pizza cut and then they cut it into really tiny pieces. Like the kind for pizza parties in elementary schools. Felt really silly eating it but it was really good. They should just normally cut the heart. How else would someone eat it.
Submitted by Dayna Burnworth on 08/26/2021
Dayna Burnworth 5 stars rating.
We visited while taking our daughter to college. The food was so good, we came back again! They could not be nicer and the pizza, calzone, and stromboli were amazing.
Submitted by Liz C on 04/09/2021
liz c 5 stars rating.
They have the BEST Chicken Cesar salads. they make there own dressing from scratch. The bread that comes with this is always fresh and warm!
Submitted by Kristina W on 11/30/2018
Kristina W 1 stars rating.
I asked for alfredo and recieved marinara sauce
And the sauce is all over the bottom of the box
Wished I would of never gave a $10.00 tip..
And how am I supposed to eat my food with out Utensils???
Don't think I'll be ordering again..
I'm sure my accountant will appreciate the Marinara sauce receipt...
Submitted by Jason Cunas on 12/29/2017
Jason Cunas 4 stars rating.
This place has the best Italian cheeseburger, they make their own patties, and meatball parm sub in the area. The service isnt the greatest. They also keep changing what comes in their sandwiches every time you visit but once you clear that up, it's delicious. I wouldn't go there for the pizza though. It's just something about the lack of cheese they put on their pies and the lack of salt in the dough. I would recommend it for the subs.
