Fiat Cafe Reviews
Submitted by Dina NYC on 08/13/2022
Dina NYC 1 stars rating.
Zero stars!!!! Waiter Paolo was very rude on all levels. Wine was flat. Tried 2 kinds. Place was nearly empty.
Worst experience I’ve ever had at a restaurant in New York. Waiter had such an attitude we canceled the entrees because we were dying to leave and go somewhere else where we could be treated better.
Anaïs Schlienger 5 stars rating.
Super cute Italian place. All brunch basics but also super good Italian dishes (not just pasta!). Family run, loved the vibes. Super affordable too.
Submitted by Anaïs Schlienger on 09/04/2022
Tyler Shore 3 stars rating.
CASH ONLY! Was not clearly marked anywhere so wanted to come on here to make people aware, as we were not. Food came quick and was reasonably priced. Vodka sauce was more of a blushing alfredo. Portion sizes were appropriate. It was a very underwhelming experience, besides the brown butter ravioli which had an amazing sauce, filled with a strong botanicality of the sage, which was very fresh. The service was very slow, and our glasses were constantly empty. The alcoholic beverages, despite being amicably priced, were very small. I’m not sure if we will be back, but if you’re looking for affordable basic italian food, and have cash, this is a good spot for you.
Submitted by Tyler Shore on 09/01/2022
Mitchell Kight 4 stars rating.
Prices are decent and the service is fine. You can tell it's family owned which means they care immensely about their food. The juice used for the Bellini was very fresh and truly elevated the drink. Honestly the only knock against Fiat Cafe is the fact they're cash only in 2022.
Submitted by Mitchell Kight on 08/17/2022
Dominic Collins 4 stars rating.
A quaint little spot just around the corner from little Italy and Chinatown, we stopped by for a very wallet friendly brunch of Eggs Benedict/Florentine/Royale and left feeling very satisfied.
It is cash only, but there is plenty of seating both inside and out and is worth visiting if you are anywhere near the area!
Submitted by Dominic Collins on 06/19/2022
Albert Husmillo 5 stars rating.
Cute little spot for a nice brunch. I enjoyed my food a lot. They make really good pasta dishes. They’re cash only, but they do have an ATM in case you forget. Nice service too!
Submitted by Albert Husmillo on 05/09/2022
Roslyn Wu 1 stars rating.
What is this? Creamy Chicken Tagliatelle in Pink Sauce but with no chicken (only 2 tiny cubes if I go digging for it). Does it look creamy to you? Picture is worth a thousand words!
Submitted by Roslyn Wu on 04/28/2022
Natalia Spotts 5 stars rating.
My favorite restaurant in NYC. Going on 10 years in New York and this place is an absolute gem. Used to live next door and would go every morning for the eggs Benedict. Moved 15 min walk away and still come 3x a week or order delivery. Excellent service from an excellent owner who is always there making sure everything is incredible. Purely, the best.
Submitted by Natalia Spotts on 04/03/2022
Tyé Grays Real Estate 4 stars rating.
Service was warm and inviting. Felt like home. My eggs Benedict was super yummy and very seasoned. Pancakes were a bit thick, crispy on the outside, buttery on the inside, fruit served on top or on the side.
Submitted by Tyé Grays Real Estate on 08/29/2021
Ashleigh McNew 5 stars rating.
Wow wow wow!!! Simply divine Italian food. We got the prosciutto with melon and mint to share. He got the Chianti, I got the Spritz. The carbonara was TO DIE for. The perfect amount of pancetta in it.
The service was lovely! Great prices and a very quiet area so you didn’t feel crowded. Can’t wait to come back to try dessert!
Submitted by Ashleigh Mcnew on 01/12/2021
