Don Angie Reviews
Submitted by Lisa Tsai on 04/27/2022
Lisa Tsai 5 stars rating.
The food is truly amazing. The drinks could use some tweaking.
The cheese inside their signature lasagna is top notch. Parmesan on the chrysanthemum salad also super delicious. Cauliflower was decent but prob should’ve gone with sweet potatoes.
Very difficult to get reservation unfortunately. Otherwise I would be frequenting.
Abbas Abbasov 5 stars rating.
Don Angie hands-down is one of the top 5 restaurants in New York City! ???????? The food and service are top-notch. We felt like welcomed to a family dinner where every little detail was well thought out, authentic, and salaciously delicious. Two of the cocktails I tried, Rosemary Clooney and the Italian Coffee Situation were excellent ????????
Submitted by Abbas Abbasov on 07/21/2022
Alex Lencz 5 stars rating.
There is such a hype surrounding Don Angie that I was worried it couldn't live up to it. I'm glad I was mistaken - the food is truly delicious and deserves all the recognition it gets.
Of course, you have to get the famous pinwheel lasagne - that was delicious. The salad (pictured) was a sleeper-hit - I'm not even much of a "salad person" but it was so light, refreshing and flavorful, I have found myself craving it since. Fantastic meal!
Submitted by Alex Lencz on 07/17/2022
Javier Kohen 5 stars rating.
This is definitely top class traditional Italian with a chef who seriously knows the craft and is brave enough to try new things. Coming back after a few years it still surprised me with its food. The portions are on the smaller side, so order accordingly, and if you can order to share!
Submitted by Javier Kohen on 06/21/2022
Tyler Colburn 5 stars rating.
Wonderful service and a very cozy atmosphere! We actually just came here for dessert and a nightcap after having dinner at Via Carota, but we ended up ordering the famous lasagna because it was my first time here and my friend convinced me that I absolutely had to try it. It was incredible and definitely worth gorging ourselves. I’m pretty sure that lasagna is 70% cheese! The desserts and the drinks were great. Can’t wait to return on an empty stomach so I can try all the other items on the menu. The last drink shown in the last photo, was some type of digestif. I can’t remember what it was called, but it was delicious; I highly recommend trying it!
Submitted by Tyler Colburn on 06/04/2022
Christopher Eu 5 stars rating.
Come for the lasagna, stay for the excellent everything else. This is one of my favourite italian restaurants in the West Village, which itself is hyper-concentrated in terms of high quality italian fare. Their uniquely spiralling lasagna definitely lives up to the hype (its different to anything you’ve probably seen before) but honestly the other dishes were better. Not pictured were the japanese sweet potatoes which were incredible, and the veal milanese which was perfectly cooked. Drinks were excellent as well and service top notch - can this place do any wrong?!
Submitted by Christopher Eu on 05/26/2022
B Heo 5 stars rating.
I was lucky to get a table for four and we had an amazing dinner. We started with stuffed garlic flatbread and chicory salad. The salad was fresh and had the great balance of sourness and sweetness. The garlic bread was full of favor. For the main we shared the famous lasagna, caramelized pasta and gnocchi. Everything was impeccable, and we especially enjoyed the caramelized pasta. The candy shaped pasta had the full of cheese inside and the sauce was flavorful. Save some space for the tiramisu. You can’t leave the restaurant without having it. Our dinner became much more special thanks to our server Jenna. She was sweet and attentive, and made our dinner memorable. I can’t wait to go back to dine at Don Angie again.
Submitted by B Heo on 03/12/2022
Reed Hatcher 5 stars rating.
This probably has to be one of the hardest reservations I’ve tried to get - but my friend finally got a call back for a standby reservation at 10pm on Wednesday just after I’d won a Broadway show lottery for the same evening! Talk about luck! Being our first time, we went with the favorites - lasagna, chrysanthemum salad, and tiramisu. The lasagna was indeed incredible, just so creamy and cooked to perfection - probably the best I’ve had. Whether it’s worth the struggle of getting a reservation is open to debate though. The salad was also good and loaded with Parmesan - not life changing though. It is still just a salad after all. The tiramisu was the perfect finish and Don Angie’s does their own creative take on the classic dessert using Black Forest cake which didn’t disappoint.
Submitted by Reed Hatcher on 02/24/2022
Maddy A 4 stars rating.
Really phenomenal food. Super hard to get a reservation here but well worth it if you do. Took off a star because the outdoor dining experience was not as nice as expected - the booths are not fully heated (there is some heat but it is not strong) and they have these loose fabric curtains that don’t block out the wind. As a result, the booths are extremely cold so you have to wear a jacket, and your food gets cold quickly. Due to the fabric curtains, you are also fully exposed to people walking and talking (or shouting) along the sidewalk. I would only make a reservation for indoors (lesson learned). Obviously, the food was amazing. The chrysanthemum salad was probably the best salad I have ever tried. The lasagna and garlic bread were excellent, and the Japanese sweet potatoes were a pleasant surprise - they are these delicious little cubes covered in sauce/cheese (for some reason I expected them to be mashed). The tiramisu was unique and tasted great, with an interesting mix of flavors and textures. I will definitely be back here, but I was disappointed with the outdoor dining experience given this is a Michelin stared resturant and we are 2 years into the pandemic.
Submitted by Maddy A on 02/20/2022
Queenie Lux 5 stars rating.
Wow. Best lasagna ever. Every bite was perfect. Melted in my mouth. The flavors and the cheese, incredible. We did not have reservations but got there 30 minutes before opening and they let us sit at the bar to drink while they got ready to open up the place. Very cozy. Worth the wait. Get reservations if you can. Great service. Great atmosphere. Wonderful food. The bartender made us cocktails based on what we liked drinking and each one was delicious!
Submitted by Queenie Lux on 12/07/2021
