Benjamin Steakhouse Reviews
Submitted by James Agena Georges on 02/26/2022
James Agena Georges 5 stars rating.
it was our first time here and all I can say it's worth every penny all the staff where very welcoming and friendly. John our waiter was amazing. if your are lucky to have him it will heighten the experience. the food was so well made. we had steak for two. It will leave you wanted more. definitely I recommend you visit.
ArLequin C 5 stars rating.
Like a previous reviewer, we too selected Benjamin's Steakhouse to try for Restaurant Week. This year's menu seemed to be similar to what was offered last season but was a mere dollar more at $60.
We chose almost the identical offerings as the other reviewer and the experience was identical. Entrees were prepared as ordered and service was crisp.
Will add that the cheese cake was awesome and must be tried.
Thanks to NYC's Restaurant Week event I now have another great steakhouse to add to my city rotation.
Submitted by Arlequin C on 08/17/2022
DAIAN JANET 5 stars rating.
This place is the best lunch in NYC!! I’ve been try soooo many popular steak house before but this place is another world!! Because they have a very good deal of lunch. Full corse is only under $40! You need to pay more than double if you want to eat same quality for everything. Everything was absolutely amazing! Steak was malt in your mouth. Cooked perfect! Jumbo shrimp cocktail was very fresh. Cheese cake was super delicious. I’ve been here over 5 times, Benjamim never disappointed to me and my besties. My hidden spot :)
Submitted by Daian Janet on 08/01/2022
shai shani 5 stars rating.
Without a doubt one of the best steakhouses in New York. The aged meats are with a very high quality, Handled on the grill professionally and according to what was ordered.
The service is very professional and friendly.
Highly recommended.
Submitted by Shai Shani on 07/30/2022
Kelli R Schulba 5 stars rating.
From the food to the drinks to the overall atmosphere, Benjamins is amazing. I had the Surf & Turf - everything was cooked to perfection, in my opinion it was the best steak I have ever had. I was also able to try the oysters, which had great flavor and tasted fresh.
Submitted by Kelli R Schulba on 03/13/2022
Yutthapong Wichitpanyarak 5 stars rating.
Really impressed by the vibes, high ceiling, decorated in a classic steakhouse styles. We came here for the restaurant week deals $59 per pax (including tax + tip) less than $80.
We got appetizers, fried calamari was really crispy from the outside but soft inside. Imported buffalo mozzarella was really refreshing.
For the entree, we got New York Sirloin and grilled salmon, both are cooked perfectly as you ordered.
Sides we selected Benjamin house fried and creamy spinach, I love the fried while thinking that spinach is too salty.
We also got desserts for this deal, we selected chocolate mousse and new york cheesecake, both are on point.
For this price, I gave it 5 star review.
Submitted by Yutthapong Wichitpanyarak on 02/13/2022
Alan Varghese 5 stars rating.
Amazing food, great presentation, nice ambience, friendly service, ample seating and very generous servings. Very strongly recommend. Loved it so much I visited it again within a week.
While the namesake steaks are splendid, we were completely blown away by there fried calamari with Marinara sauce and the desserts of NY cheesecake and chocolate mousse cake. They also have a nice bar.
The restaurant is frequented by celebrities and some politicians, so you may spot one during a visit.
Submitted by Alan Varghese on 02/12/2022
Iman Hosseini 4 stars rating.
Old school steakhouse which has lagged behind. It's good but lacks the modern touch of competitors. The sides to steak are bland. Cheesecake is meh.
The staff are great and atmosphere is really authentic.
Submitted by Iman Hosseini on 02/02/2022
Arianna Silvis 5 stars rating.
I’ve been coming to Benjamin’s since I was young and it’s my favorite steakhouse in the city! The porterhouse and wedge salad is a must try! The staff always gives great service and I couldn’t be happier with my experience. If you get a chance to sit upstairs, do it!
Submitted by Arianna Silvis on 12/28/2021
LOVE 5 stars rating.
I went on a Saturday evening for dinner . Reservations were made but wasn’t required . Our waiter was attentive and patient with us as we looked over the menu . The ambience was comfortable and high class it made me feel extra fancy lol. Vaccination is required for indoor seating but a beautiful
outside seating setup is available (non heated) .
We started of with the sizzling Canadian bacon with a side of a Caesar salad , and a crab cake it was good . My date and I both decided on the surf and turf and lobster mac . I had Long Island tea for my drink of choice which was very tasty and strong by the third one I was cross eyed ???? , my date had a triple shot of casamigos a full top shelf bar is available.
I got my steak medium it was cooked PERFECTLY! Lobster and shrimp was tender I would definitely get this again . The lobster Mac was delicious as well I wish I could ask for the recipe ????.
I’m not sure how expensive it was because my date didn’t let me see but by the prices on the menu it’s expensive so please be ready to spend $$$.
This place definitely has a date night special occasion vibe but can also pass for a girls night . Make reservations if you’re in the area . Happy eating ????????
Submitted by Love on 10/25/2021
