Bay Ridge Bakery Reviews
Submitted by Annie Byrnes on 01/29/2020
Annie Byrnes 5 stars rating.
I bought my husband a birthday cake here at the very last minute. It was German chocolate and it was absolutely deliciously moist and rich. The woman who waited on me was very sweet and I was impressed at how much writing she was able to fit on top of the cake. I also thought that for the quality of the cake it was very well-priced. Wish I had gotten more items given how good it was, but I will definitely be back!
Eileen BR 5 stars rating.
Love this bakery! We order the Greek Macaroons and the Greek Easter bread (Tsoureki) and Baklava. Everything's always fresh and yummy!! Great for gift giving!! The store is very clean and organized. The people at the counter are professional polite and friendly! We've also ordered our Birthday cakes from this lovely bakery and our guests were very pleased!!!
Submitted by Eileen Br on 06/17/2022
Rola Turk 1 stars rating.
I ordered cake from this place for my aniversiry I paid 50$ and I was expecting to have fresh baked cake. But what they did was so bad, They added old chocolate cake and cover it with fresh cream plus the strawberry filling was worse than the cake it self.
Submitted by Rola Turk on 05/10/2022
V M 5 stars rating.
Been here a few times, owners and staff are so pleasant... Everything we have tried, is fresh, delicious, and prices are very reasonable for great quality . For true chocolate lovers a must try "Triple chocolate" has cherry filling, "German cake" has coconut" and cute Mice cake has almond pieces. Strawberry shortcake, fruit tart... great when having company or to bring over for family/friends well packed..
Submitted by V M on 03/08/2022
Anna D. 5 stars rating.
Ordered a birthday cake from Florida for my son in Brooklyn. Spoke to a lovely lady named Peggy who worked with me to order and make payment. Thank you so much for helping us provide my son with a special treat for his special day!
Submitted by Anna D. on 09/15/2021
Evelyn Chen 5 stars rating.
Gooooood !!!!!
Cheaper prices but cake is so good !
Best cheesecake in bay ridge !
Submitted by Evelyn Chen on 08/01/2021
Michael 2k3d 5 stars rating.
I really like the quality of the sweets here. Cakes are delicious and fresh while being reasonably priced.
I bought a fruit tart on Christmas day and it was made fresh at 11:30am.
I hope this place never closes. Times are tough and I would gladly pay twice the prices they charge for their professionally and made-with-love sweets. Thank you guys for being open on Christmas day 2020. Merry Christmas.
2/15/2021 update. It's presidents day and they are not only open but open until 8pm. It happens to be my younger son's birthday. I love their family business traditional feel inside and the courtesy and professionalism of their staff is so refreshing everytime I visit. I bought a birthday cake for my son for $24 dollars that is a work of art and is what he wants and bigger than my entire family can finish in one sitting. They are amazing. Try them. You won't regret it even if you aren't a sweets person.
Submitted by Michael 2k3d on 02/15/2021
Mariia Simanov 5 stars rating.
We have been buying pastries from Bay Ridge Bakery for the past four years and it has been a great experience every time. Delicious fruit tarts, eclairs, macaroons, cookies and bunch of different cakes. We always buy from this bakery each time we want to treat our friends or family.
Submitted by Mariia Simanov on 08/20/2020
E Masoud 5 stars rating.
This is the iconic bakery of Brooklyn, with the best cakes I've ever had. You will find a wide variety of assorted cakes, cookies and unique pastries for any occasion. I applaud the owners for maintaining their quality and services for all these years. Keep up the good work!
Submitted by E Masoud on 06/17/2020
Steve 5 stars rating.
Offering a wide variety of freshly baked cookies, pastries and bread.
My favorite is their cheesecake, but it must be consumed within a day or two of preparation as it ages quickly. Chocolate lovers will be disappointed as their brownies are good but often sold beyond their expiration point and their eclairs are not chocolatey enough.
For holidays they usually have free samples by the cash register which I always find hard to resist.
They use quality ingredients which is reflected in their pricing and are one of the best bakeries in Bay Ridge for non-chocolate items.
Submitted by Steve on 12/26/2019
