Piscataway Pizza Reviews
Submitted by ONLY GOD CAN JUDGE ME on 02/01/2022
ONLY GOD CAN JUDGE ME 1 stars rating.
The Pizza is delicious but the customer service sucked. My brother and I were there standing for 5 minutes there was a worker sitting at the table on his phone. He looked at us then went back to his phone. The other worker was making Pizza looked at us and the third worker also looked at us and they kept talking. The worker who was on his phone finally then got up had a convo with the other workers laughing like we were invisible. He finally came over to us. Good food or not I will never come there again they need to work on respecting all customers and their customer service skills
Stephanie Ramos 5 stars rating.
Awesome service. You don't expect to have amazing service at a pizzeria. This place goes above and beyond. We stopped here on the way home after my daughter's spring recital for a little celebratory pizza and we were blown away by the service. They server was funny and attentive and great with our little guy that was tired and asking for everything. On top of the great service, the food was delicious. We had a chicken salad and large pizza. Nothing extravagant but everything was flavorful and fresh which is everything you need from a pizzeria. I took the menu so we can order take out.
Submitted by Stephanie Ramos on 05/15/2022
kdmagee11 5 stars rating.
We came in late night, almost closing time. Food was so great and the customer service was greater. My family and I laughed so hard while we was there. It was like getting a double dose of goodness all under one roof. We ordered pizza, salad, and garlic knots. The price wasn't that bad. The comedy is what made it even better to enjoy the food. We will definitely be coming back again for the food and the comedy. Thank you Sir for making our night.
Submitted by Kdmagee11 on 05/13/2022
Cindy 1 stars rating.
The delivery guy wouldn't give me my order until I verified my name, even though he delivered the order to the address it was ordered to... The carrot cake was stale and tasted like whatever it had been stored in the fridge with. The pizza was ok.
Submitted by Cindy on 04/27/2022
James Heidenthal 1 stars rating.
I had two slices just to hold me over till dinner. The pizza was hard as a rock and little or no flavor. Maybe I just caught them on an off time. One thing I have to say is that it’s extremely clean. I hope if I do try them again that they prove my review wrong.
Submitted by James Heidenthal on 04/27/2022
Gregorio rivera 5 stars rating.
Big slices great daily specials great people. Did a special request for me also.
Submitted by Gregorio Rivera on 01/21/2022
Jena Rose 5 stars rating.
If you're looking for an authentic Italian dish, I recommend the chicken saltimbocca. This place knows how to make it the right way; I'm Italian and it reminds me of my own recipe. The cannolis are also delicious! Don't be fooled by the appearnace, great food.
Submitted by Jena Rose on 01/17/2022
Mabes Mansing 1 stars rating.
Completely dissatisfied with this order. I ordered a Sicilian slice of pizza, tiramisu, and lasagna. They sent me a hard old slice of cheese pizza which was disgusting. The tiramisu slice was OLD AND HARD, tasted like it’s been sitting in the fridge for days, not to mention how small the slice was and I paid 5 something for it. And the lasagna was swimming in oil. First and LAST time I will be ordering from this place. Paid almost 30 dollars for this order. This place doesn’t even deserve one star. I will be waiting for my refund from Uber Eats. Please see the pictures to see for yourself.
Submitted by Mabes Mansing on 12/27/2021
Afterhours Fabrication 4 stars rating.
Good food, stromboli and cold sub were on point. Lost a star at the cheese steak though, with sliced cheese only on top it leaves half the sandwich just meat and bread.
Submitted by Afterhours Fabrication on 04/11/2019
Jason Cunas 2 stars rating.
The slices here are big but they sacrifice quality for size. I honestly dont know why I keep giving this place a chance to step it up. Their pizza is flavorless and if you try to touch it up with Garlic or oregano, it's like it rejects it.
Submitted by Jason Cunas on 04/28/2017
