The New York Diner- Valrico Reviews
Submitted by Mike Swearingen on 08/10/2021
Mike Swearingen 5 stars rating.
I eat a Keto lifestyle/diet, they were very accommodating of my request for steak and eggs only.
Very pleasant and friendly staff.
I had a friend in from out of town and it was a nice place for us to eat a late breakfast or lunch and visit awhile.
Would definitely recommend giving this one a try!
Leah Reed (Leah) 4 stars rating.
Very friendly staff. Busy as can be! Big portions. Good food but hit or miss (Cuban was ok, patty melt was good, and veggie skillet was delicious!) I will definitely be going back.
Submitted by Leah Reed (leah) on 06/07/2022
Ashley Nicole 5 stars rating.
I don’t know what the hell was wrong with Jim A. two comments below but lawddddd did Mr.Fancy pants miss out on his biscuits and gravy with eggs and potatoes. That was one of the best biscuit and gravy skillets I’ve had in a long time. Abby was our waitress and she was fabulous and friendly and this visit was with every penny.
Submitted by Ashley Nicole on 05/01/2022
Joseph Drury 1 stars rating.
My wife and I always go there for Sunday breakfast this Sunday was very unacceptable don't like hair in my food. big long black ones and it wasn't one it was two in different parts of the meal brought it to their attention and they said well we'll knock some money off the bill it was like a few dollars are you kidding me that was disgusting and I'm never going back after going for 5 years and he doesn't talk to his wife very nice either in front of people the owner he screams at her
Submitted by Joseph Drury on 04/06/2022
Highly Favored 5 stars rating.
My mom and I had a great experience here. Our server/one of the owners was super sweet and welcoming. We sat at the 'bar' area and were salivating watching meals prepared meticulously. We loved our omelette, fries, muffin, French toast and cuban bread. Place was packed for a Monday but service was great.
Submitted by Highly Favored on 03/28/2022
Gretchen Desch 5 stars rating.
First time here. Great service. I notice time says 7am to 2pm. Got full quick. Staff was great with each other. Would come back here. Bring a jacket if you get cold.
Submitted by Gretchen Desch on 03/16/2022
Jim A 1 stars rating.
I was at the New York diner Saturday morning with a friend. We ordered breakfast. I ordered sausage gravy and biscuits with two over easy eggs on the biscuits, then the sausage gravy on top of that, Then hashbrowns on top of it all. When the waitress brought my plate it wasn’t made like I told her. Now she wrote all this down on our pad as to how I wanted it prepared. The sausage gravy was poured on top of the eggs and hash brown. When I asked The waitress if she could have it remade the way I wanted it she came back with the same plate and said that the cook who is also the owner said he’s not going to waste that plate that he could not and would not remake it. I told him that I would not pay for it and I would not eat it. While my friend finished his breakfast I end up having to go somewhere else to eat breakfast that morning before we left on a trip. On the way out I told him that I would be writing a review. He said I don’t care have a good day. Needless to say we will not ever go there again. And by the way no one was wearing a mask that was preparing food
Submitted by Jim A on 02/20/2022
helen matthews 5 stars rating.
Friendly staff! For was hot and delicious. Was even lucky enough to try a new stuffed french toast! I hope it's on the Special menu soon!
Submitted by Helen Matthews on 10/15/2021
Sandra Osborne 5 stars rating.
Great food and the service is always a pleasure to speak with. The onion rings are amazing which are made in house.
Submitted by Sandra Osborne on 08/31/2021
Jia Liu 4 stars rating.
We have been coming here for years. Food is good. Though the last time we went, the food tasted different than usual (it did not have much flavor). Very good local breakfast and lunch spot.
Submitted by Jia Liu on 12/28/2020
